The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland (ICAS) Crest
 
 
 
Forgot Password
HOMEABOUT ICASMEMBERSCA STUDENTS
Click to view Auditing
Click to view Charities
Click to view Financial Reporting
Click to view Other Business Issues
Click to view Public Sector
Click to view Research Centre
Click to view Tax
Click to view Technical Query Service
   You are here : Technical, Tax & Research : Research Centre Publications : Reporting on Internal Control in the UK and the US: Insights from the Turnbull and Sarbanes-Oxley Consult
Print:Feedback:Email

Reporting on Internal Control in the UK and the US: Insights from the Turnbull and Sarbanes-Oxley Consultations

Researchers: Spira and Gowthorpe


The Report

The changes that were brought about to internal control reporting by the Sarbanes-Oxley Act and the Turnbull guidance provide a real opportunity to look at the implications of these requirements and the process of policy development.

This report reviews the two different approaches to internal control reporting in the US and UK, both in terms of definition and regulatory approach, before contrasting the responses of respondents to the Sarbanes-Oxley section 404 consultation and the Turnbull review consultation in 2004/5. These contrasting views provide a novel insight into the role of consultation in regulatory change in two important regimes.

The report also demonstrates that, despite the perception of an ‘Anglo-American’ approach to corporate governance, there are distinct differences in approach to internal control reporting in the UK and US.

The report highlights significant issues for further research including: the impact of internal control reporting on organisations and audit committees; the implications for international convergence of different definitions of internal control; a cost comparison between a principles-based and a rules-based system for internal control disclosure; and the impact of disclosure requirements on the risk appetite of boards.

ISBN 978-1-904574-31-6

Price £15.00

This report can be ordered in hard copy or downloaded in PDF format. There is also an Executive Summary to give a brief overview of the report.


To access the order form, please click on the link below

Order Form

To view the Executive Summary, please click on the link below

Executive Summary PDF

To view the whole report, please click on the link below

Full Research Report PDF

Share |
Contact  | Disclaimer  | Privacy  | Terms & Conditions  | Sitemap  | Accessibility